University of Idaho graduate student, Katy Benoit, reported her professor for sexual harassment following the dissolution of their consensual relationship. She told school officials he’d threatened her with a gun on multiple occasions. On the very same evening the university informed her that her abuser resigned, Katy was shot to death on her front porch.  

27-year-old Brian Shaffer was attending the Ohio State University College of Medicine in 2006. He had a seemingly bright future ahead of him, but after bar hopping with a friend on the night of March 31st, 2006, he went through the front doors of the Ugly Tuna Saloona, and was never seen again.

When Binghamton University student, Haley Anderson, stopped answering her friends’ texts, they knew something was very wrong. A subsequent search revealed Haley was dead in a mutual friend’s apartment. But this friend was nowhere to be found. An investigation would reveal a murder, a runaway to Nicaragua, and justice that would span two continents.